Thread
Printable Version

Silent Witness Season 1-18 General Discussion Thread (Spoilers)

3x04 Fallen Idol (2)

Gemma's biological father being killed my her mother because she thought he killed her was tragic as he had an alibi but the father of the baby she was carrying being her stepfather must make him a suspect but Katie killing her was a shock

TOP

3x05 Divided Loyalties (1)

How tragic that Maggie's death wasn't discovered for several days in which time her baby daughter died but the mother dying of a heroin overdose would seem just like a double tragic accident until the DCI was shredding documents and was against Maggie's exhumation after a second suspicious death was bizarre

TOP

3x06 Divided Loyalties (2)

The DS taking the DCI hostage because of what happened to his family was an interesting twist but the DS killing himself before revealing where the DCI was held hostage was a surprise but it would of been poetic justice that it was were the mother and baby died

TOP

3x07 Brothers in Arms (1)

What a gruesome way to die in a combine harvester but with the wife having an affair with the farm labour there two suspects right from the start and Sam getting a note saying she's made a mistake was bound to get her to have a closer look at the body

TOP

3x08 Brothers in Arms (2)

Interesting conclusion with as many killers as bodies and it all started because what the soldiers did 1985 but Sam and Marie were both lucky as Marie was holding a gun on Sam who put herself in the line of fire

TOP

4x01 Gone Tomorrow (1)

Waiting for news on the helicopter carrying 16 men that crashes in the North Sea would be horrendous but what a stroke of luck the first body found was still alive and the pilot having a heart attack a week after his wife thinks he got the all clear from his medical is suspicious

TOP

4x02 Gone Tomorrow (2)

Another stroke of luck that the pilot had been stopped for speeding and was given a blood test for alcohol before flying and the mechanic now committing suicide but all because of a rota bolt all those lives lost and one walking survivor was a nice ending

TOP

4x03 A Kind of Justice (1)

Brian was lucky to get out as he was covered in the victims blood but he didn't last long as the victim was a gangster and for some strange reason I think this was done by a copper trying to start a turf war between the gangs

TOP

4x04 A Kind of Justice (2)

The kid on the bike stealing money from gangster was bound to get beaten up and was Sam's coroner file also disappearing is looking more like there is a police involvement but a left handed copper trying to recreate a right handed killers MO on an old case was stupid

TOP

4x05 A Good Body (1)

12 victims from the fire in the cinema was tragic but identifying all but one of the victims was interesting as all the bodies were badly burnt but who would of thought after facial reconstruction the final body was supposed to have been killed years ago and someone was convicted of the murder

TOP

4x06 A Good Body (2)

The medical records disappearing the night before they got there was to much of a coincidence and was looking more like a police cover up as they sent an innocent man to jail but Caldwell's solicitor being involved was a surprise and after spending years in prison only to be killed by his solicitor after he was released was another waste of life

TOP

5x01 The World Cruise (1)

The cleaner finding the twin brothers Jake and Henry dead in their home was tragic and the scum-bag of a boyfriend using her key to steel the money under the bed did make him look guilty but finding a concentration camp numbers on their arms could also indicate a hate crime

TOP

5x02 The World Cruise (2)

The fact the scum-bag of a boyfriend took the money from under the bed not knowing they were dead it would of served him right if he got charged for their murder and ironic he left £23,000 behind was amusing but the killer getting revenge for what they had done to his brother in the concentration camp was understandable

TOP

5x03 Two Below Zero (1)

The avalanche uncovering the naked body of a young woman was a stroke of luck but finding the second body and both girls being strangled in a similar fashion was interesting as the first girl disappeared 15 years earlier but seeing Henry in the bar flirting with the girls does make him guilty

TOP

5x04 Two Below Zero (2)

Who would of thought the killer was killing the girls to save them from Henry's who was just a dirty old man

TOP

5x05 Faith (1)

Sam storming off when the police didn't agree with her initially findings was a first and the fact that she may have a tumour herself didn't help her judgement but having witnesses downstairs when the gun went off you would think the wife did commit suicide, being asked to do an autopsy on the remains of Sister Constance, a nun who died forty years ago was strange but interesting

TOP

5x06 Faith (2)

Sam being asked to do a second post mortem after being asked by the victims mother was great as Sam's evidence proved she couldn't of pulled the trigger herself and finding the stereo with the sound of the shotgun was the icing on the cake

TOP

6x01 The Fall Out (1)

What a tragedy having to investigation a multi-vehicle collision that results in the death of 11 people but the fact that some of the police were tampering with crash scene made this very interesting as one placed an empty alcohol bottle while another removed something from the vehicles and finding a severed arm that didn't belong to any of the victims was an added twist

TOP

6x02 The Fall Out (2)

If only the police had been honest with Sam she wouldn't of blown their undercover operation and the fact the police caused the accident made why the two officers tampered with the scene more understandable

TOP

6x03 Kith and Kill (1)

Investigating the death of Derek, his wife and youngest daughter was interesting and the two older children survived the attack but one is in serious condition and in a coma were very lucky

TOP

Thread